« Previous Entry |
Back to Blissful Knowledge
| Next Entry »
March 03, 2008
EVERY TIME I THINK I'M OUT, THEY PULL ME BACK IN
Sigh.
Did John McCain really have to throw a bone to the discredited mercury-mongers? A further data point that you shouldn't let your kids grow up to be Presidential candidates.
I'd like to believe that Megan is right and that McCain pandered out of a combination of ignorance and not wanting to tell a potential voter that her firmest beliefs about her child's autism are without basis. There may be more to it than that (or to the idea that McCain's science adviser is Don Imus). McCain does have a minor history with the mercury types: specifically, he has met with representatives of an organization dedicated to pushing the mercury connection (not that there's anything wrong with meeting with them) and sent a letter (together with Sen Lieberman) to Ted Kennedy (and the Republican ranking member) asking themto hold hearings on the topic.
(Note that this same organization sent letters to certain of the other Presidential candidates asking them to respond to various autism-related questions. The staffs of Senators Biden, Edwards and Obama (see the January 2, 2008 section) made sure that they didn't buy into the mercury/vaccine claims.)
That being said, McCain does not have much of a record on pushing the thimerosal issue (quite unlike the lunatic Dan Burton in the House). (Writing a letter to a fellow Senator is a reliable way of getting noisy constituents to shut up and keep the campaign contributions coming.) His campaign website has nothing on the topic (unlike Barack Obama's). Absent further developments, there is little reason to think that McCain would push the issue or that he really knows or cares much about it. But I do wish someone would set him straight.
I also liked Jonathan Kulick's lovely retort.
UPDATE: Arthur Allen has more on how McCain is connected to the mercury militia. Allen also notes that "McCain isn't known to have any familiarity with vaccine safety issues."
Posted by Dr. Manhattan at 10:18 PM | Permalink
Comments
The foregoing entry may leave the impression that there is something on the Obama website supporting the thimerosal theory of autism. There isn't (at least at the cited page -- I could not search the entire site). I think all Dr. Manhattan meant is that the Obama site addresses autism policy. I read the entire entry carefully and searched for the words "mercury," "thimerosal," and "vaccine." There was nothing.
Posted by: Paul Turner | March 4, 2008 4:10 PM
The merits of McCain's position on an issue tends to correlate negatively with the amount of science involved, especially if the science doesn't involve blowing stuff up.
Posted by: Crank | March 7, 2008 5:15 PM