« Previous Entry |
Back to Blissful Knowledge
| Next Entry »
November 18, 2003
YOU GO, GIRL
Newly permalinked Naomi Chana has recently experienced some frustration with her Torah-study class in her synagogue:
[H]ere is an abridged list of things I could have said yesterday but didn't:
- "Blessing is not the same thing as prayer."
- "Also, blessing is not the same thing as arguing for direct divine intervention, but if you go on for much longer I'm going to be praying for God to pull the fire alarm."
- "We were talking about Abraham, remember? And this book we call the Torah?"
- "Could we please not rehearse free will vs. predestination before doing some background reading? And by 'we,' I mean 'you.'"
- "I don't care what you believe in. Really. Truly. Honestly. With all my heart and soul and might."
...
- "Ah, yes. Just the time to mention Islam. Some of us try to actually make a connection to the text, but I see you're brave enough not to bother with that."
...
- "I'm sorry, this is 'Torah study.' The 'share your Personal Spiritual Journey Unasked-For' class is next door."
...
- "You do not have a clue. You would not have a clue if an angel of the Lord appeared to you and told you that you were going to give birth to a clue after ninety years of barrenness."
There's more.
I wouldn't mind having her in my shiur. Yes, even in Orthodox synagogues, shiurim can get hijacked by the spiritual kin of Ms. Chana's co-participants.
Posted by Dr. Manhattan at 9:32 PM | Permalink
Comments
Dr Manhattan -
Im not sure what you are trying to get at with this post. I read the full post, and it just seems to reek of intellectual and religious snobbery. Im all for questioning, especially in the shiur format, but there is a big difference between rigorous thinking and reminding yourself how much better you are than other people.
Dr. Bronx, MSIII
Posted by: Anonymous | November 19, 2003 6:40 PM