« Previous Entry |
Back to Blissful Knowledge
| Next Entry »
December 30, 2002
BUT IS IT KOSHER?
It seems that science is growing closer to being able to grow meat in a lab.
The piece is pretty fascinating. As Jonah Goldberg points out, the propsect of meat without animals raises fascinating questions:
...I am curious what the animal rights and eco-types would say to the proposition of lab grown meat -- assuming they could get past their deep luddism. After all, the suffering of farm animals would be sharply curtailed if not eliminated. Forests wouldn't need to be cleared for cattle and billions(?) of acres of forest land around the world could be allowed to revert to wilderness, improving the quality of our air and water.
Of course, even if we perfected the technology overnight (which we wouldn't), there are some obvious downsides: millions of farm animals would probably have to be killed since their would no longer be much economic utility in feeding them. Worse, billions of people around the world would have their traditional social, political and economic arrangements shattered. Our attachment to the land would be even more attenuated. Whole new quasi-religions and political movements would develop around the need to eat "authentic" meat. Anyway, it's an interesting topic for lazy-day pondering.
All true. But those questions pale in comparison to the most important one of all: would such laboratory-grown meat be kosher? Would stakes genetically from cattle and bison, without the intermediate steps of existence as a living animal and shechitah, be kosher? What about grown pork - would the non-existence as an actual pig be enough to render it kosher?
I need to research this issue a little more closely.
Posted by Dr. Manhattan at 1:47 PM | Permalink
Comments
It should be kosher, the same way vegetarian bacon is. Either way, it's fake meat.
Trekkie nerd that I am, I once asked a Rabbi about pork from a replicator and that's the answer I got :-) .
Posted by: Esty | December 31, 2002 12:56 PM
From the hard-core jewish sources. The Midrashic tales of the Garden of Eden state that prior to the eating of the forbidden fruit,it was forbidden to schecht the animals. Meat without shechita and preparation was provided directly to Adam and Eve. Perhaps the Kosher laws are only in place for meat that was once a living creature. Since that has been the sole source of meat for millenia it was never an issue before.
Posted by: Dave P | December 31, 2002 3:50 PM